I listened to this in audiobook during my commute to and from work. It was a LONG book; I actually had to re-request it from the library in order to finish it.
I really enjoyed this book. I was so intrigued by the plot summary that I had some high expectations. It reminded me a lot of Harry Potter with the magic and the lessons, etc, and of course I absolutely love anything relating to fairy tales!
The main theme of this book was that you don’t have to be who people think or want you to be. You can choose your own path and make your own decisions. Beauty is on the inside.
Sophie was utterly horrific. I hated listening to her. She went from annoying to completely evil over the span of the book. Agatha was such a good, loyal friend to Sophie, and Sophie just used her. She is really a terrible person. It’s frustrating that Agatha just won’t let go of that friendship. Sometimes friends go opposite directions and that’s ok. That’s life. But Agatha fights till the bitter end to save her friend.
Agatha – I LOVE Agatha. It’s been a long time since I’ve enjoyed a main character so much. She isn’t your typical heroine. She loves to wear black, she hates conforming to what people want her to do, she doesn’t realize that she has a good soul underneath her not as pretty exterior. She has very low self-esteem and it takes her almost the entire book until she realizes her worth and her goodness.
I really liked how the book focused on friendship. Even though Sophie and Agatha were told that they could never be friends (a princess and a witch can never be friends), they never stop fighting to get home together.
There were a few times that the story seemed to move slowly and there were some points where it seemed to wonder to things that didn’t seem important. In the end Agatha’s trip to Sader’s office is important, but I feel like it was just thrown in there for Agatha to have the revelation at the end of the book. It wasn’t written in as seamlessly as it could have been.
I hated the way the book ended!!! It just ENDED. There was ZERO, I mean absolutely NO wrap up at all. After such a long book I wanted some closure for our characters but there was none. The author obviously knew he was going to write a series. But I would have appreciated just a little wrap up.
Overall I really enjoyed it. Looking forward to where the author takes the series.